Antitrust

[Antitrust] 1/15 Paper Presentations

Class meeting time: 9:00

Important notes:

  • The order of presentations will be decided by drawing when we meet.
  • The reviewer is expected to examine the research question, the assumptions, and the logical connections of the arguments, as well as checking the citations, among other things.
  • All are expected to read everyone else’s paper, in addition to the one you review. This is your last chance to shore up your participation score.
  • Learn to take good control of your time. Highlight your main arguments when time is short, and elaborate when time permits.
  • Each session lasts 1:30 or so. (see the time allocation table below).

Presenter-reviewer Pairing (but NOT the order of presentations):

presenter reviewer
凱心 宇哲
惠暄 羅嵐
羽芯 惠暄
宇哲 羽芯
乃云 凱心
羅嵐 乃云

Time Allocation:

presentation 30 min.
review 10 min.
open discussion 25 min.
author’s final response 10 min.
moderator’s time 15 min.
LRTW

[LRTW] Final AO presentations

Class meeting time:

  • 12:30 (Fri.): 11am
  • 1/9 (Mon.): 10am

Important notes:

  • As a presenter, you are expected to present your arguments anew, as in a conference; in other words, pretend we haven’t heard them before.
  • As a reviewer, you are expected to review the logical coherence of the arguments, the bluebooking of cited resources, and presentation performance.
  • All are expected to read everyone else’s AO, in addition to the one you review. This is your last chance to shore up your participation score.
  • Learn to take good control of your time (note the time is allocated differently from the other class). Highlight your main arguments when time is short, and elaborate when time permits.
  • Each session lasts roughly 1 hr. (see time allocation table below).

Order of Presentations: to be decided via lottery on site.

Pairing (not the order of presentations) :

presenter reviewer
12/30
之穎 子楠
子楠 羽芯
惠暄 宇哲
1/9
乃云 凱心
凱心 乃云
宇哲 惠暄
羽芯 之穎

Time Allocation:

presentation 20 min.
review 10 min.
open discussion 15 min.
author’s final response 5 min.
moderator’s time 10 min.
Law & Economics

[lawecon] 6/21-22 Paper Presentations

Class meeting time: 9:30 on 1/21 (Tue.).

Important notes:

  • The order of presentations will be decided by drawing at the beginning on Thursday.
  • The reviewer is expected to examine the research questions, the assumptions (explicit or hidden), the analytical models of the paper, as well as the strength and weakness of its arguments. You’re the reviewer; be critical.
  • The reviewer should also look out for improper copy-pasting from other people’s works, inaccurate citations, and poor bluebooking jobs.
  • All are expected to read everyone else’s paper, in addition to the one you review. This is your last chance to shore up your participation score.
  • Learn to take good control of your time. Highlight your main arguments when time is short, and elaborate when time permits.
  • Each session lasts 1:20 or so. (see the time allocation table below).

Presenter-reviewer Pairing (but NOT the order of presentations):

presenter reviewer
吳宇 林君蓉
陳怡辰 蕭明月
徐彥婷 黃麗瑾
林君蓉 羅蘭
蕭明月 徐彥婷
葉欣茹 鄭之穎
莊敏瑄 葉欣茹
鄭之穎 徐敏榕
黃麗瑾 陳怡辰
徐敏榕 吳宇
羅蘭 莊敏瑄

Time Allocation:

presentation 25 min.
review 10 min.
open discussion 20 min.
author’s final response 10 min.
moderator’s time 15 min.
LRTW

[LRTW] 1/18 Final AO presentations

Class meeting time:

  • 9:00 AM on 1/18 (Mon.).

Important notes:

  • As a presenter, you are expected to present your arguments anew, as in a conference; in other words, pretend we haven’t heard them before.
  • As a reviewer, you are expected to review the logical coherence of the arguments, the format of cited resources, and presentation performance.
  • All are expected to read everyone else’s AO, in addition to the one you review. This is your last chance to shore up your participation score.
  • Learn to take good control of your time (note the time is allocated differently from the other class). Highlight your main arguments when time is short, and elaborate when time permits.
  • Each session lasts 1 hr. (see time allocation table below).

Order of Presentations: to be decided via lottery on site.

Presenter – reviewer Pairing:

presenter reviewer
吳宇 黃麗瑾
林君蓉 徐彥婷
徐彥婷 陳怡伶
莊敏瑄 陳怡辰
陳怡伶 葉欣茹
陳怡辰 吳宇
黃翊軒 莊敏瑄
黃麗瑾 黃翊軒
葉欣茹 林君蓉

Time Allocation:

presentation 20 min.
review 10 min.
open discussion 15 min.
author’s final response 5 min.
moderator’s time 10 min.
Antitrust

[Antitrust] 1/7-8 Paper Presentations

New Class meeting time: 12:00 (noon) on 1/7 (Thu.).

Important notes:

  • The order of presentations will be decided by drawing at the beginning on Thursday.
  • The reviewer is expected to examine the research question, the assumptions, and the logical connections of the arguments, as well as checking the citations, among other things.
  • All are expected to read everyone else’s paper, in addition to the one you review. This is your last chance to shore up your participation score.
  • Learn to take good control of your time. Highlight your main arguments when time is short, and elaborate when time permits.
  • Each session lasts 1:30 or so. (see the time allocation table below).

Presenter-reviewer Pairing (but NOT the order of presentations):

presenter reviewer
陳怡辰 徐彥婷
黃麗瑾 陳怡辰
鄭之穎 黃麗瑾
莊敏瑄 葉欣茹
葉欣茹 蕭明月
吳宇 莊敏瑄
蕭明月 徐敏榕
林君蓉 鄭之穎
徐敏榕 吳宇
徐彥婷 林君蓉

Time Allocation:

presentation 30 min.
review 10 min.
open discussion 25 min.
author’s final response 10 min.
moderator’s time 15 min.
Law & Economics

[lawecon] 6/26-27 Paper Presentations

Class meeting time:

  • 10:00 AM on 6/26 (Fri.).

Important notes:

  • The reviewer is expected to examine the research question, the assumptions, and the logical connections of the arguments, as well as checking the citations, among other things.
  • Though you have just finished your big final exam, all are still expected to read everyone else’s paper, in addition to the one you review. This is your last chance to shore up your participation score.
  • Learn to take good control of your time. Highlight your main arguments when time is short, and elaborate when time permits.
  • Each session lasts 1:30 or so. (see time allocation table below).

Order of Presentations & Presenter-reviewer Pairing:

order presenter reviewer
1 翊軒 伊婷
2 信宇 家瑋
3 芊儒 楓茹
4 芝穎 翊軒
5 伊婷 信宇
6 楓茹 芝穎
7 家瑋 芊儒

Time Allocation:

presentation 30 min.
review 10 min.
open discussion 25 min.
author’s final response 10 min.
moderator’s time 15 min.